The Genre Promise

The Genre PromiseAnother of the Five Reads of Story literary agent Jessica Berg teaches authors is the genre promise.

Every genre novel is a contract. When the reader signs up, you owe them the specific satisfaction of that genre. The premise of the story has to signal the kind of contracted you’re offering. This is why genre fiction comes with specific covers, blurbs and synopses. Importantly, the plot then delivers on that promise.

  • Romance promises the relationship will resolve into a happy ever after or Happy for now, and that it will be earned.
  • Thriller promises rising tension against a ticking clock and then release.
  • Mystery promises to fairly answer a puzzle with a satisfying surprise or twist.
  • Fantasy promises to play out with magic and wonder.
  • Literary and upmarket promises a worthy and challenging question that the protagonist must negotiate, usually without clear-cut answers.

The premise of the story has to signal the promise it’s making from the start, and it better payoff at the end.

Mashups

So what happens with genre-mashups? The same rules apply. The genre-blend has to be clear along with the promises, and it has to payoff at the end.

Margaret Atwood, Muriel Spark, Octavia Butler all write fantasy within literary frameworks. These are award-winning classics.

On a more commercial level, Pride and Prejudice and Zombies wears it’s heart on its sleeve. The title alone conveys the promise, as does Abraham Lincoln, Vampire Hunter. It does what it says on the cover. The title is the premise.

The hidden clause

So what happens when the promise is unclear, or the author performs a bait-and-switch? It doesn’t have to be intentional.

Sanderson often repeats the example of the fantasy novel that waited until half-way to flip it’s tropes. Sold on its opening fantasy promise, many readers hated the reversal of tropes at the half-way point and DNF’d it. Other readers found it below-par and DNF’d the book before they reached the turning point where everything changed into a masterly reversal.

For both sets of readers, the book broke the promise.

According to Sanderson, the author didn’t understand why.

A personal promise

That brings me to the genre promise for my upcoming YA project.

The first book synopsis and cover nail the premise. Three fantasy characters navigate a dangerous city after the fall of Empire.

The second volume synopsis sets up the mission to find Yari’s father, with a more mysterious cover that alludes to the landscape and setting.

 

 

 

 

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top